Book 2: Obligations

Section 383: Court may reduce an excessive penalty

Title 2: Contracts Chapter 3: Earnest Money and Stipulated Penalties

Text of the section

Statutory text (Thai original)

ถ้าเบี้ยปรับที่ริบนั้นสูงเกินส่วน ศาลจะลดลงเป็นจำนวนพอสมควรก็ได้ ในการที่จะวินิจฉัยว่าสมควรเพียงใดนั้น ท่านให้พิเคราะห์ถึงทางได้เสียของเจ้าหนี้ทุกอย่างอันชอบด้วยกฎหมาย ไม่ใช่แต่เพียงทางได้เสียในเชิงทรัพย์สิน เมื่อได้ใช้เงินตามเบี้ยปรับแล้ว สิทธิเรียกร้องขอลดก็เป็นอันขาดไป
นอกจากกรณีที่กล่าวไว้ในมาตรา ๓๗๙ และมาตรา ๓๘๒ ท่านให้ใช้วิธีเดียวกันนี้บังคับ ในเมื่อบุคคลสัญญาว่าจะให้เบี้ยปรับเมื่อตนกระทำหรืองดเว้นกระทำการอันหนึ่งอันใดนั้นด้วย

Verbatim from the Royal Gazette / Office of the Council of State

English translation

If a forfeited penalty is disproportionately high, the court may reduce it to a reasonable amount. In determining what is reasonable, every legitimate interest of the creditor shall be taken into account, not merely the creditor's property interest. Once the penalty has been paid, the right to claim a reduction is extinguished.

Apart from the cases provided for in section 379 and section 382, the same rule applies where a person promises a penalty in case that person does or refrains from doing a certain act.

Verified against the Thai source text, 6 November 2026

Traduction française

Si la pénalité encourue est d'un montant excessif, le tribunal peut la réduire à un montant raisonnable. Pour apprécier ce qui est raisonnable, il est tenu compte de tout intérêt légitime du créancier, et non seulement de son intérêt patrimonial. Une fois la pénalité payée, le droit d'en demander la réduction est éteint.

Hors les cas prévus à l'article 379 et à l'article 382, la même règle s'applique lorsqu'une personne promet une pénalité pour le cas où elle accomplirait ou s'abstiendrait d'accomplir un acte déterminé.

What this means for foreigners

A penalty (bia prap) is a sum or other performance the parties fix in advance for non-performance. Section 379 covers a penalty in money and section 382 a penalty in some other form, as the Supreme Court explained in 8982/2568 and 1303/2568. Section 383 lets the court cut an excessive penalty down to a reasonable amount, weighing every legitimate interest of the creditor, not only money. The label does not matter: in 8982/2568 the court said a clause is a penalty whatever words the parties use, so 'damages', 'fine' or 'compensation' clauses are all open to reduction. Punitive damages under the consumer procedure law are different and are not reduced under section 383.

For foreigners renting a house, condominium or office, the decisions are directly useful. In 1574/2566 a tenant who left an office lease early faced clauses making it pay all rent to the end of the term and forfeit its deposits; the court treated both as penalties, refused the rent claim and held that keeping the deposits was reasonable compensation. In 923/2549 a holdover charge of 2,000 baht a day per unit was excessive and the court awarded 10,000 baht a month per unit instead. In 4290/2566 an early termination fee of 40% of the remaining rent on a vehicle lease was cut to 10%.

Penalties also appear in family arrangements. In 1303/2568 a husband had promised to give up all sin somros if he assaulted a family member; the court enforced the promise but reduced it, leaving him a share of the land.

Two cautions. First, once a penalty has been paid the right to ask for a reduction is lost, so dispute an excessive charge before paying it. Second, a deposit paid when signing a property purchase may be earnest (mat jam) rather than a penalty; none of the decisions below decides that point, and the contract wording matters. When the contract is ended, section 391 governs restitution alongside any penalty claim.

Our guide: lease agreements in Thailand.

Supreme Court decisions on this section

  1. Supreme Court Decision No. 1574/2566

    Facts: A company leased office space for three years from a property fund, paid lease and service deposits, and terminated early without fault of the landlord, which then claimed rent for the rest of the term as well as keeping the deposits.

    Held: Clauses requiring the tenant to pay all rent for the full term and to forfeit the deposits fixed damages in advance and were penalties that the court may reduce under section 383. The contract ended on termination, so under section 391 the landlord could not claim rent as if it continued, only damages; the Court of Appeal's ruling that the forfeited deposits were reasonable damages was affirmed.

    Why it matters: A tenant who leaves early is not automatically liable for the whole remaining rent; the court can treat that clause and the deposit forfeiture as reducible penalties.

    อันมีลักษณะเป็นการกำหนดค่าเสียหายไว้ล่วงหน้า ถือว่าเป็นเบี้ยปรับ ซึ่งหากสูงเกินส่วน ศาลจะลดลงเป็นจำนวนพอสมควรก็ได้
  2. Supreme Court Decision No. 923/2549

    Facts: A tenant of two registered 15-year commercial leases at the Chiang Mai Night Bazaar stayed on after the leases expired; one lease charged 2,000 baht a day if the premises were not returned on expiry, the other only after termination.

    Held: The daily charge in the first lease was a penalty fixed in advance and excessive, so the court could reduce it under section 383; the second lease's charge did not apply because the lease expired rather than being terminated, but the landlord could claim damages in tort under section 438. A creditor who claims the contractual penalty cannot also claim tort damages for the same loss. The first instance award of 10,000 baht a month per unit was restored.

    Why it matters: Holdover charges in Thai leases are often reduced, and the wording (expiry or termination) decides whether they apply at all.

    แต่เบี้ยปรับที่กำหนดไว้นั้นสูงเกินส่วน ศาลมีอำนาจลดลงเป็นจำนวนพอสมควรได้ตามประมวลกฎหมายแพ่งและพาณิชย์ มาตรา 383
  3. Supreme Court Decision No. 4290/2566

    Facts: A company returned a leased pickup truck after one year and four months of a five-year lease; the contract required 40% of the remaining rent on early termination in the second year and the lessor claimed 253,380.65 baht.

    Held: The early termination clause fixed damages in advance and was a penalty; weighing the lessor's legitimate interests, the claim was excessive and the court reduced it to 10% of the unpaid rent of 633,451.61 baht, i.e. 63,345.16 baht. The judgments dismissing the claim were reversed.

    Why it matters: Early termination fees in leases are penalties that a court may cut to a reasonable figure.

    นับว่าสูงเกินส่วนเห็นสมควรปรับลดลงและกำหนดค่าเสียหายในส่วนนี้แก่โจทก์ร้อยละ 10 ของเงิน 633,451.61 บาท
  4. Supreme Court Decision No. 1303/2568

    Facts: During the marriage the husband signed a family agreement promising not to assault his wife or family and, if he did, to agree to divorce and give up all rights in their sin somros; he later assaulted their daughter.

    Held: The agreement was not a contract between spouses on management of property but a written bond of good behaviour under section 1516 (8), valid and not contrary to section 150. Giving up all sin somros was a penalty in a form other than money under section 382, which the court found excessive and reduced under section 383, ordering transfer to the wife of 6/10 of each of the seven plots instead of all of them.

    Why it matters: A spouse's promise to forfeit all marital property for misconduct can be enforced, but the court may scale it down.

    เป็นข้อตกลงที่มีลักษณะเป็นการชำระหนี้อย่างอื่นที่มิใช่ใช้เป็นจำนวนเงินเป็นเบี้ยปรับตามประมวลกฎหมายแพ่งและพาณิชย์ มาตรา 382
  5. Supreme Court Decision No. 2345/2565

    Facts: A person engaged as brand ambassador for a watch and jewellery brand posted an Instagram photo wearing a competitor's jewellery, in breach of the contract.

    Held: The breach entitled the brand to terminate and claim the agreed damages, which were a penalty reducible under section 383; the trial court's reduction to 300,000 baht was appropriate. The Court of Appeal's dismissal was reversed, and on termination the ambassador could claim no further fees.

    Why it matters: Agreed damages in service and endorsement contracts are enforceable but are routinely reduced to what is reasonable.

    ที่ศาลชั้นต้นปรับลดโดยกำหนดให้จำเลยทั้งสองร่วมกันรับผิดจำนวน 300,000 บาท นั้น เหมาะสมแล้ว
  6. Supreme Court Decision No. 3290/2566

    Facts: A loan agreement provided that interest unpaid for over a year would be added to the principal and compounded every year until full payment.

    Held: The written compounding clause was valid under section 655 and not an unfair term, but it fixed compensation for non-payment in advance and was a penalty under section 379; it was excessive, so the court reduced it under section 383 by allowing interest to be compounded only once.

    Why it matters: Even lawful compound interest clauses in loans can be cut back as penalties.

    ศาลฎีกาเห็นว่า ข้อตกลงดังกล่าวเป็นเบี้ยปรับที่สูงเกินส่วน เห็นสมควรลดเบี้ยปรับลง โดยกำหนดให้โจทก์คิดดอกเบี้ยทบต้นได้ครั้งเดียว
  7. Supreme Court Decision No. 6779/2567

    Facts: A hire purchaser missed one instalment and returned the car; the finance company sold it and claimed the shortfall under the contract.

    Held: Returning the car terminated the hire purchase under section 573 and the purchaser was liable for the shortfall, but the shortfall clause fixed damages in advance and was a penalty reducible under section 383 para 1; the court set it at 147,000 baht, giving 153,000 baht in all with loss of use.

    Why it matters: Shortfall claims after a repossession or return are penalties the court will reduce to a reasonable sum.

    ข้อตกลงที่จำเลยจะรับผิดชำระค่าขาดราคาให้แก่โจทก์ตามสัญญาเช่าซื้อ ข้อ 10.4 มีลักษณะเป็นการกำหนดค่าเสียหายไว้ล่วงหน้าอันเป็นเบี้ยปรับ
  8. Supreme Court Decision No. 8982/2568

    Facts: A client sued a lawyer who had handled his civil and criminal cases negligently and abandoned them, claiming damages and punitive damages under the consumer case procedure law.

    Held: A penalty is damages fixed in advance by the parties, whatever words they use, and may be reduced under section 383; punitive damages are an additional sum aimed at the wrongdoer's conduct, so they are not a penalty and section 383 does not apply to them. The court awarded 200,000 baht damages with interest and 100,000 baht punitive damages without interest.

    Why it matters: It sets the boundary of section 383: agreed penalties can be reduced, court-imposed punitive damages are a separate matter.

    ค่าเสียหายเพื่อการลงโทษจึงไม่ใช่เบี้ยปรับและไม่อาจนำมาตรา 383 มาปรับใช้กับการกำหนดค่าเสียหายเพื่อลงโทษได้

Related sections

Questions about this section

My landlord wants to keep my whole deposit and charge rent to the end of the lease. Can a Thai court reduce that?

Possibly. In 1574/2566 the Supreme Court treated a clause requiring all remaining rent and a deposit forfeiture clause as penalties under section 383, refused the claim for future rent once the lease had ended, and accepted only the deposits as reasonable compensation. The result depends on the actual loss and the contract wording.

Can I still ask for a reduction after I have paid the penalty?

No. Section 383 says that once the penalty has been paid, the right to claim a reduction is extinguished. If you think a charge is excessive, dispute it in writing before paying, or pay only the undisputed part, and take advice on the contract wording.

Does it matter whether the contract calls it a fine, damages or a penalty?

No. In 8982/2568 the Supreme Court said that any amount fixed in advance for non-performance is a penalty whatever word the parties use, and the court may reduce it if it is excessive. Punitive damages awarded by a court under consumer law are different and are not reduced under section 383.

Can a court reduce a promise to give up marital property?

Yes. In 1303/2568 a husband promised to give up all sin somros if he assaulted a family member. The court enforced the promise as a bond of good behaviour but held that losing everything was an excessive penalty in kind and reduced it, so the wife received 6/10 of each plot rather than all of it.

Firm annotation

Section 383 is part of Book 2 (Obligations) of the Thai Civil and Commercial Code. This entry is awaiting firm-authored commentary; the statutory text above is verbatim from the Office of the Council of State (OCS Krisdika) Thai source, with the English translation from the FAO/UN FAOLEX repository. Always rely on the Thai original for legal proceedings.

Core section

Why this matters in practice

For lawyers: bring Section 383 as a counterclaim or plea in any case involving an outsized contractual penalty; the court must take all the creditor's legitimate interests into account, not merely financial loss. For laypersons: if a contract requires you to pay a very large penalty, you may ask the court to reduce it even if you are in breach.

Legislative history

Part of the original Civil and Commercial Code codification; no major subsequent amendment.

Keywords

  • penalty reduction
  • court discretion
  • proportionality
  • creditor's interests
  • disproportionate penalty

Supreme Court decisions interpreting this section

  1. Supreme Court Judgment No. 3811/2562 (2019)

    A front-end fee payable on the day the credit agreement is signed is consideration for the use of the facility and depends on that agreement coming into existence; signing it is a condition precedent and, under section 366 paragraph 2, the parties are taken to have intended the written credit agreement to be decisive. If it is never signed the lender has no right to the fee at all. But a separate part of the fee, payable on signing the letter of acceptance and forfeitable if the borrower fails to perform, is a promise to pay a sum on doing or not doing something - a penalty within section 383 paragraph 2, which the court may reduce to a reasonable amount. A lender that forfeits under such a clause exercises a contractual right, is not in default, and owes no interest on the part it is later ordered to return.

    A bank approved a 656,000,000 baht facility on terms requiring a front-end fee of 13,120,000 baht on the day the credit agreement was signed, of which 9,560,000 baht was payable on signing the letter of acceptance and forfeitable if the borrowers failed to perform. The borrowers could not get their directors to sign the credit agreement within the extended deadline. The Supreme Court held the front-end fee was consideration for use of the facility and that signing the credit agreement was a condition precedent, the parties intending the written agreement to be decisive under section 366 paragraph 2, so without it the bank had no right to the fee. The 9,560,000 baht already paid was, however, a penalty under section 383 paragraph 2, and the Court of Appeal had properly reduced it to 2,000,000 baht: the bank claim to have lost interest by not lending the money elsewhere was unsupported, and preparing the credit analysis was its staff ordinary work. Finally, because the forfeiture was a lawful exercise of the bank contractual right it was never in default, so it owed no interest on the 7,560,000 baht it had to return, and that part of the order below was set aside.

    Read source text (deka.in.th, secondary reproduction)

  2. Supreme Court Judgment No. 11379/2556 (2013)

    A freely negotiated penalty clause is not automatically an unfair contract term but remains reviewable under Section 383 if disproportionate.

    A contractual penalty of 2% per month for breach was freely agreed and constituted a penalty clause; the court held it was not an unfair contract term under the Unfair Contract Terms Act but remained subject to reduction if disproportionate under Section 383.

    Read source text (deka.in.th, secondary reproduction)

Selected case summaries from the firm's research collection. Source links identify the materials used; they do not, by themselves, establish authentication against the official court record.

Our Supreme Court decision pages on this section

Showing decisions in our database that cite this section. The list updates automatically when new decisions are added.

Supreme Court citation record 297

Cited in 297 Supreme Court decisions (1955 to 2025)

Selected citing decisions

This list is selected automatically, weighted towards judgments that turn on this section rather than ones that merely recite it when passing sentence. It has not yet been reviewed by the firm.

Most often cited alongside

Sections that appear in the same judgments as this one most often. The figure is the number of decisions.

Counted across a fixed snapshot of the firm's corpus taken on 8 August 2026: 83,652 Supreme Court decisions, 1921 to 2026. The live corpus is larger and grows every week. The count is complete; the stated year range trims rare outliers so it describes where the citations actually sit. These figures are computed by us and are not official court statistics. How we count these, and what we measured

Frequently asked questions

Can a court reduce a penalty that has already been paid?

Once a penalty has actually been paid over, no. Section 383 paragraph 1 provides that where the forfeited penalty is disproportionately high the court may reduce it to a reasonable amount, weighing every legitimate interest of the creditor and not merely the financial one, but that once the penalty has been paid the right to ask for a reduction lapses. The qualification that matters is what counts as payment. Section 383 paragraph 2 extends the court's power of reduction to a promise to pay a sum on doing or not doing something, and where a party forfeits money it was already holding under such a clause, rather than the other side handing the penalty over, the court can still assess whether the sum is excessive and order part of it returned. A lender that forfeits under such a clause is exercising a contractual right, is not in default, and owes no interest on the part it is later ordered to return.

Cite this section

Cite this section

  • Plain citation Civil and Commercial Code, s. 383 (Thailand)
  • Academic citation Civil and Commercial Code (Thailand), s. 383. ThaiLawOnline, https://www.thailawonline.com/thai-civil-code/section-383/ (accessed 16 November 2026).
  • Thai citation ป.พ.พ. มาตรา 383
  • Permalink https://www.thailawonline.com/thai-civil-code/section-383/
  • Embed on your site <blockquote cite="https://www.thailawonline.com/thai-civil-code/section-383/"><p>If a forfeited penalty is disproportionately high, the court may reduce it to a reasonable amount. In determining what is reasonable, every legitimate interest of the creditor shall be taken into account, not merely the creditor's property interest. Once the penalty has been paid, the…</p><footer>Civil and Commercial Code, s. 383 (Thailand): <a href="https://www.thailawonline.com/thai-civil-code/section-383/">ThaiLawOnline</a></footer></blockquote>

The Thai text is authoritative. The English is an unofficial translation by ThaiLawOnline, free to reuse with attribution.

This is educational reference, not legal advice. Consult a qualified Thai lawyer before relying on any provision.

Scroll to Top
WhatsApp LINE Call Book